Vol. ?Published wheneverPrice: free
The Whenever

No. 1 ·The dossier

The phantom million

Newsletters announce their subscribers by the million. I went through the 2026 data to see how many of those people open, click and pay.

In 2017, Tim Huelskamp and Andrew Steigerwald emailed a Google Doc to 78 friends and relatives. They called it 1440, after the number of minutes in a day. In June 2026, the company announced a $101 million valuation, said it had been profitable since 2023, and put a number on its audience:

4,700,000

subscribers claimed by 1440 in June 2026 (company figure)

The newsletter business loves this kind of story, and it always ends on the same figure: sign-ups. Axios says it has about 6.7 million across its editions, TLDR roughly 8 million across 14 newsletters, The Athletic 10 million.

That figure is easy to inflate and tells you surprisingly little. An email address doesn’t read anything. So I went through the few public datasets that let you look past it, with one question in mind: when a newsletter says “a million,” how many people are actually there?

You’re reading this, so at least one newsletter got through to you. Most don’t.

A hundred Americans

Start with the readers. In August 2025, Pew Research Center asked 5,153 American adults how often they get news from email newsletters. Picture them as a room of a hundred people.

Guess first

Out of 100 American adults, how many get news from newsletters often?

50out of 100

Tap a square or a label.

How often do you get news from email newsletters? Out of 100 U.S. adults; each square is 1% of respondents. The total is 99 because of rounding and non-response. Source: Pew Research Center, survey conducted Aug. 18–24, 2025, published Feb. 19, 2026

Forty-three never do. Twenty-six rarely. The people who do it often fill a single row: six of them. Ask which platform they prefer for news and only three choose newsletters.

Even people who get news this way don’t keep up. Among them, 62% say they don’t end up reading most of the newsletters they receive, and 71% subscribe to fewer than five.

One number in the survey goes against the grain.

6

get news from newsletters often

7

paid for or donated to a news newsletter in the past year

More Americans paid for or donated to a news newsletter in the past year than read one often. That doesn’t mean people pay for things they never open: these are two separate questions, and at this scale rounding matters. Still, the people who pay are about as numerous as the regulars, which makes them a real audience rather than a handful of diehards.

Money, in other words, is less scarce than attention.

A thousand emails

Now the publishers’ side. In the first half of 2026, the email platform Omeda analyzed 1.95 billion newsletter sends from media companies. It splits them into two groups: B2B titles (trade and professional) and consumer, or enthusiast, newsletters (sports, hobbies, passions). Here is what becomes of a thousand emails in each.

not opened "opened" (some by machines) clicked unsubscribed
"opened"
309
30.9%
clicked
10
click rate 1.01%
unsubscribed
0.88
0.088%
clicks per reader who leaves
11
What happens to 1,000 newsletter emails. Each dot is one email. The chart combines medians that were computed separately, so read it as an order of magnitude, not as a real campaign. Source: Omeda, Newsletter Benchmark Report for Media H1 2026 (publisher medians)

Out of a thousand B2B emails, about ten get a click. In enthusiast newsletters, nearly thirty. The open rate says very little: some of those “opens” come from mail apps that preload messages to protect your privacy.

Clicks are a better signal, but they have ghosts of their own. In Omeda’s first-quarter 2026 data, 87.3% of recorded click activity was flagged as bot-driven. Security software that scans links before anyone reads the email is a common culprit. Omeda doesn’t say whether its benchmark filters these clicks out, so take every click rate in this story as a ceiling.

The gap between the two groups should survive that caveat, unless the bots happen to prefer one kind of newsletter. What caught my eye is the unsubscribe rate. Enthusiast newsletters lose slightly more readers, 1.12 per thousand sends against 0.88 for B2B. But for every reader who leaves, they get about 26 clicks. B2B newsletters get 11.

So people quit passion newsletters a little more easily, and click on them almost three times as often while they stay.

I haven’t seen this ratio in any of the benchmark reports, and I think it deserves a place on every dashboard: clicks per unsubscribe. It tells you, in one figure, whether your emails make people curious faster than they make them tired.

Size doesn’t buy attention

The Athletic, the sports site owned by The New York Times, publishes something rare in its advertising kit: the size and open rate of each of its newsletters. There are ten, from general sports to Formula 1. If bigger meant more widely read, the dots would slope down to the right.

Guess first

Which one has the higher open rate?

40%45%50%55%60%100K1Msubscribers →overall open rate claimed: 49%The PulseFull TimePrime Tire
Show the data as a table
NewsletterTopicSubscribersOpen rate (%)
The PulseGeneral sports4,300,00044
NFL NewsletterNFL1,520,00055
The WindupBaseball960,00051
The Athletic FCSoccer803,00054
The BounceBasketball780,00047
Until SaturdayCollege football695,00056
MoneyCallSports business467,00051
Red LightHockey452,00053
Full TimeWomen's soccer192,00057
Prime TireFormula 166,00046
Subscribers and open rates of The Athletic's newsletters. Log scale: each tick is ten times bigger. Hover over or tap a dot. Source: The Athletic advertising kit (publisher figures, not audited)

They don’t. The Pulse, the flagship, has 4.3 million subscribers, sixty-five times as many as Prime Tire, the F1 newsletter, with 66,000. Their open rates are almost the same: 44% and 46%. The best of the lot is one of the smallest. Full Time, which covers women’s soccer, has 192,000 subscribers and a 57% open rate.

Across these ten, size explains less than 2% of the variation in open rates (the correlation is −0.13 on a log scale). Ten newsletters are too few to draw a rule from, but enough to show that size on its own predicts very little.

These numbers hide a second ghost. Add up the ten editions and you get 10.2 million, close to the 10 million The Athletic claims for its newsletters. That total counts subscriptions, though, not people. A Knicks fan signed up for The Bounce, The Pulse and the NFL newsletter is counted three times. And The Pulse alone accounts for 42% of the pile.

What a list is actually worth

Then there’s the money. The newsletter platform beehiiv, which hosts thousands of publications, has published medians drawn from more than 2,500 paid newsletters. Before you look at them:

Guess first

Out of 1,000 free subscribers, how many end up paying?

50out of 1,000

Across the platform, 0.62% of free subscribers become paying ones, about six in a thousand. In sports the rate is 1.93%, three times higher. A typical annual price is around $100. Move the slider to see what that means for a list of your size.

386
paying subscribers
$38,600
a year, gross, in theory (at $100/yr)

Theoretical yearly revenue by list size, log scales

$1K$10K$100K$1M1K10K100K500KExtra Points
All-niche medianSports median Extra Points (real case)
Illustration only: a platform median applied to an imaginary list, before fees, taxes and production costs. Not a forecast. Source: beehiiv, The State of Paid Newsletters 2026; Extra Points case study

The black dot, well above both lines, is Extra Points, a newsletter about the business of college sports. According to a beehiiv case study, it has just over 27,000 subscribers, 2,000 of whom pay, and brings in about $200,000 a year. That’s a 7.4% paid rate, nearly four times the sports median. Extra Points is not a typical sports newsletter, though. Its readers work in the industry it covers, and part of its revenue comes from licensing and data products rather than subscriptions alone.

Churn takes some of the shine off. In sports, the median paid subscriber cancels at a rate of 7.76% a month, which works out to about 13 months of paying life. After a year, roughly six in ten have gone, so a paid newsletter has to replace more than half of its paying readers every year just to stand still.

The price of an email address

How much, then, is a single subscriber worth? The numbers in this story give four different answers, plus one cost.

beehiiv sports median, simulated · revenue per year$1.931440 · revenue per year, mostly ads$5.74Extra Points · revenue per year$7.411440 · valuation per subscriber$21.491440 · cost to acquire one subscriber$3.30–$5
What one subscriber is worth, in dollars: yearly revenue, then a valuation, then what 1440 pays to acquire one. These figures don't measure the same thing. Math: $38,600 ÷ 20,000 (beehiiv sports simulation); ~$27M ÷ 4.7M (1440); $200,000 ÷ ~27,000 (Extra Points); $101M ÷ 4.7M (1440's valuation); just under $1M a month to add 200,000–300,000 subscribers (1440). Source: beehiiv; 1440 via Adweek and PR Newswire

According to Adweek, 1440’s valuation is four times its annual revenue of roughly $27 million. Spread over 4.7 million subscribers, that comes to about $5.74 per subscriber per year, most of it from advertising. The company also spends just under a million dollars a month to add 200,000 to 300,000 subscribers, or somewhere between $3.30 and $5 each.

Put side by side, those two numbers sum up the business: pay about four dollars for an address, then earn about six a year from it for as long as the reader sticks around. At more than $21 per subscriber, the valuation is a bet that they will. What investors are paying for is a habit, millions of people opening the same email every morning.

Counting differently

The subscriber count isn’t false. It just answers the wrong question. Every dataset in this story points to the same conclusion: what a newsletter is worth depends less on how big its list is than on how much of that list is actually there. Call it density.

If I had to replace the subscriber count with three numbers, I’d pick these:

clicks

per unsubscribe. Do your emails make people curious faster than they make them tired?

payers

per 1,000 sign-ups. The median is 6. In sports, 19.

actives

at 90 days. How many sign-ups clicked at least once this quarter?

Six Americans in a hundred get news from newsletters often. It’s a small group, but it comes back, day after day. For anyone starting a newsletter, the goal is less to build a huge list than to become one of the few emails those people still open.

Which might explain why one newsletter makes you work so hard to get in.


Methods and sources

Audience figures are publisher claims or advertising kits, not audited numbers. The beehiiv and Omeda data describe their own platforms, not the whole U.S. market. The Axios and TLDR figures are the publishers’ own and weren’t independently verified. Derived numbers (clicks per unsubscribe, the correlation, value per subscriber, acquisition cost) are my own calculations.

Correlation: Pearson coefficient between log10(subscribers) and open rate across The Athletic’s ten editions, r = −0.13 (r² ≈ 0.017). Clicks per unsubscribe: median click rate ÷ median unsubscribe rate, 1.01 ÷ 0.088 ≈ 11 and 2.86 ÷ 0.112 ≈ 26. Paying life: 1 ÷ 7.76% ≈ 12.9 months; share still paying after 12 months: (1 − 0.0776)^12 ≈ 38%.

  1. Pew Research Center, Email Newsletters as a Source of News (Feb. 19, 2026) and methodology
  2. Omeda, Newsletter Benchmark Report for Media H1 2026
  3. Omeda, Email Engagement Report Q1 2026 (bot-driven clicks)
  4. beehiiv, The State of Paid Newsletters 2026 (June 22, 2026)
  5. beehiiv, Extra Points case study
  6. The Athletic Advertising, Newsletters (advertising kit)
  7. 1440 via PR Newswire, valuation announcement (June 4, 2026)
  8. IBTimes, on 1440’s founding and valuation
  9. Pulse 2.0, summarizing Adweek’s reporting on 1440’s revenue and acquisition spend (June 9, 2026)